Episode 7. Lucy Swanston of Nutshell Creative

Season #2

In this episode, I am joined by Lucy Swanston, the Managing Director of Nutshell Creative and Chair of the Strategic Mailing Partnership (SMP). With over 20 years at the helm of Nutshell, Lucy shares her journey from starting a business in her back bedroom during a recession to leading a multi-award-winning agency that bridges the gap between creative strategy and print production.

We discuss the importance of staying in your lane while remaining agile, and how print remains a vital, enduring ecosystem in an increasingly digital world. The conversation delves into the shift from a 'manufacturing-led' mindset to one that leads with value and strategy.

Lucy explains why consistency is the most critical word in marketing, warning against the 'New Year’s resolution' approach to social media that quickly falls by the wayside. We also explore the surprising resurgence of direct mail among younger generations and why, as we look towards 2026, building credibility and human trust is more important than simply churning out automated content.

Key Takeaways

  • Consistency is the foundation of visibility and long-term marketing success.
  • Transitioning from a 'printer' to a strategic partner requires leading with value rather than machinery.
  • Younger generations have a high engagement rate with physical mail because it feels tangible and personal.
  • Authenticity in AI-generated content is vital to maintaining trust with your audience. 
  • Specialising in a specific sector or 'vertical' allows you to become a specialist rather than a generalist.
  • Values like trust and transparency must be lived and breathed, not just used as marketing buzzwords.
  • Effective time management is the biggest challenge for print leaders trying to grow their business.
  • Integrated campaigns that blend digital and physical channels are far more powerful than single-channel efforts.
  • Leadership success often comes from hiring for personality and cultural fit first.
  • Print is a resilient, thousands-year-old ecosystem that continues to evolve rather than disappear.